At the start of the year, when the tech giant showcased its experimental generative AI project, share values of major game publishers like the publisher behind GTA noticeably dipped. The underlying fear was evident: if interactive worlds could be created from a few written words, what role would there be for vast teams of creators?
However, Take-Two's CEO, speaking recently, voiced little worry over such tools. "I was kind of stunned by the market's reaction," he stated. "Seeing it as a threat to our industry is rather misguided; AI tools are beneficial for game development."
The Core Argument: Assets vs. Hits
He went on to explain that while tools may create quality assets, this capability does not translate to producing a blockbuster. "These tools can assist in producing assets, but they will not help you create hits," he argued. "There are countless assets out there now. It doesn't matter if you push a button or requires weeks of work—you have an asset."
"The notion that in some way advanced AI would enable an individual to push a button and generate a hit, market a hit, and deliver it to many millions of consumers... it's a laughable notion," stated the CEO. "That has never been the case with entertainment."
Zelnick noted that creating a hit on the level of NBA 2K or iconic series "is a completely different animal and absolutely requires human touch [and] human creativity."
A Level Playing Field?
In his view, these new tools does not level the playing field "even the littlest bit" between prompt-writers and experienced studios. Development tools to make games already exists, evidenced by the thousands released every year. However, the hits consistently come from established publishers and, occasionally, a breakout indie developer.
The Music Analogy
To illustrate his point, Zelnick—who describes himself as tech-positive executive—discussed the example of AI-composed songs. "Currently, there are programs that allow you input a description and get a polished track generated at you," he explained. "It may sound professional, but I challenge anyone to hear it more than once."
He emphasized that AI's true value lies in enhancing productivity and managing "mundane office tasks," rather than substituting for the essential human creativity behind beloved franchises.
On the horizon, Take-Two Interactive is set to release Rockstar Games' GTA VI later this year. The industry will no doubt be looking for any commentary on if generative AI could impact the development of that titanic title.